Health and Safety Forum

Knowledge Network | Health and Safety Forum

Reply To: Switching Incidents and Guidance

  • Graeme Johnson

    Member
    16 June 2026 at 12:10 pm

    Rob

    Good question, you will find a huge gap in reported events (EEA Safety alerts) vrs the anecdotal evidence that I hear around the traps as a member and chair of the EEA SSPG.

    Common themes from anecdotal evidence and the EEA issued safety alerts:

    1. Switching instruction integrity

    Missing steps (earthing, isolation)
    Inadequate checking despite multiple reviewers
    Poor release request quality feeding bad instructions

    2. Control discipline breakdown

    Deviating from instructions without reissue
    Continuing switching when uncertainty exists
    Failure to stop when conditions change

    3. Earthing errors (critical risk)

    Earth left applied during livening
    Incorrect earth placement
    Failure to verify earth status before restoration

    4. Isolation assurance failures

    Incorrect isolation points on permits
    Assumptions based on testing instead of isolation
    Delays in isolating supply (fault scenarios)

    5. System information / configuration risk

    SCADA vs field mismatch
    Labelling errors
    Incomplete commissioning updates

    6. Human factors

    Distraction (permit error)
    Handover gaps (NOC)
    Over-reliance on process rather than verification